Shooting Down the Avro Arrow

Andrew Coyne has a pointed and interesting column in Maclean’s looking at RIM co-CEO Mike Lazaridis’ claim that allowing Nortel’s CDMA wireless business and LTE R&D unit be sold to Ericsson would be akin to the decision to cancel the Avro Arrow aircraft in 1959.

“Let us learn from our history and not make the same mistake again,” Lazaridis sold a parliamentary committee that held an emergency hearing last week.

Coyne’s suggests the Avro Arrow was a disaster, and the decision to kill it was the right move.


[Slashdot] [Digg] [Reddit] [del.icio.us] [Facebook] [Technorati] [Google] [StumbleUpon]
This entry was posted in General and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.
  • zeroman

    Avro Arrow was innovation ahead of its time. Nortel is a disaster.

    If the Arrow lived on with Avro refining the technology and design, Canada would be forefront in jet fighters. It would be on the stage with the US, Russia and France producing some of the best of breed.

    Importantly, Canada would also be self-reliant for its defense. How many billions are we paying to Boeing, Lockheed and others today. And what percentage of those billions come back in the form of jobs to Canada? What is the state of the aerospace industry in Canada?

    If the US and Russia had axed their space programs due to failures, would we ever have the technologies we use today.

    This is the analogy that some of us are tryng to bring up. Agree Nortel is a disaster. But at least the Government can be smart enough to impose restrictions and requirements putting the Canadian economy, innovation and jobs at the very top of any agenda.

    If not 10, 20, 30 years down the road Canada like its defense will not be self-reliant. It will spend billions on foreign manufcaturers with a small negligible percentage of jobs in Canada. Which will not be top line jobs but more on the lines of call centers, support etc.

    The difference between Canada and other technology developed countries is culture. In other countries such as the US, it is ok to fail as long as you pick yourself up and move to the next thing, as long as you learnt from the mistake and becoming successful. In Canada, failure means pack up and go home. Here taking risk is taboo, no matter what you do, whether you are an entrepreneur or an executive requiring to make critical discussions.

  • qcboris

    You Canadians and your Avro Arrow. You came up with a good idea 50 years ago and are still talking about it. Even a blind squirrel finds a nut now and then.

  • tiredofitall

    You're wrong, and to prove it we will continue to kick your ass at hockey!

  • watching…

    Really?

    Go Preds!

  • protosphere

    The Avro Arrow didn't have a bonus happy management creating the largest fraud in Canada that was followed by endless laughable hype to endless contradictions and zero credibility.

    But hey… we still have the Canada Space Arm, the Blackberry, world class talent, colorful money, health care, high taxes, great beer, etc., and a wonderful sense of humor. =)

  • protosphere

    go Jays go… oops =)

  • Resigned_From_NT

    Dude, you're making us look bad with that comeback, especially considering that we haven't won the Stanley Cup since 1993 (won by the Habs, barely Canadian)!

    Health care anyone?

  • tiredofitall

    Argoooooos!

  • tiredofitall

    You make a good point about Canadians being afraid of failure, even though you are generalizing. If everyone was like that, I'd be painting on my cave walls this afternoon.

  • tiredofitall

    A wonderful sense of humour (Canadian spelling) is essential for survival up here eh.

  • Norterrible

    It is human nature to be afraid of nature, which is why the vast majority of people are afraid of failure, not just hosers to the north. As for painting your cave walls, it is likely those who lived in them that gave us of our fear of failure today in our instincts since failure to them meant being eaten alive.

  • GoProto

    What part of canada is known as the “sunshine coast”? I read that Joni Mitchell stayed at a cottage there (when it was warm) when she went on retreat from LA.

  • fabrice002

    Can anyone see RIM's statements – whoever made them – as anything other than self-serving trite?

  • zeroman

    point taken about generalization. yes no everyone is like that but the number of risk takers is small I bet. overall that seems to be behavior here. do not rock the boat. I have life. I am happy in my corner. Comfort over going above and beyond.

    there are some really successful people who made it. short supply though.

  • tiredofitall

    It`s just a case of their Canadians beat our Canadians. Is it 50% (or more) of the players are from Canada? Gotta be proud of that! Having said that, a good hockey player is a good hockey player, no matter where they are from. But collectively, as a country, we are the BEST!

  • tiredofitall

    Zero is right though about our culture. We, in general, avoid risk taking. Nothing wrong with that, it's just not going to make you really successful in business often. BTW, I myself am really not a risk taker. Maybe that's why I'm still in this damned cube, er, I mean cave.

  • exnt_x_2

    Here's a story that may help clarify things …

    There was this man who walked into a sea food store in Maine one day and noticed two baskets of lobsters set out. The odd thing was that one of the baskets had a lid on top of it while the other didn't.

    Curious, the fellow asked the proprietor why the difference in the baskets. “Oh, the lobsters in the basket with the lid are American lobsters,” he says.

    Scratching his head, the customer asked why the other basket didn't have a lid. “Well, those are Canadian lobsters. Whenever one of 'em trys to climb out of the basket all the others reach up and pull 'im back down.”

  • scalppeeler

    WTF is your point?

  • exnt_x_2

    Touched a nerve, did I?

    It's just an example of the Canadian sense of humour.

  • less

    The global village lives in abject fear of those ever warmongering Yank lobsters…

  • less

    A persons got to know his limitations. Mike knew his, but he bluffed his way through by playing the hawk, with the doves all a-flutter, letting him clear The Path for them.

    Now he's gone all lovey-dovey by tuning out, turning off and dropping out with his head held high (something obviously musta got lost in translation there)

  • exnt_x_2

    Yeah, and they've got nukes.

  • exnt_x_2

    Oh, ya. The point.

    The point is that Nortel's the basket without the lid.

  • 1st

    “You make a good point about Canadians being afraid of failure”? More like afraid of winning: At least our Gov. afraid of rub the wrong side of our “partners/neighbors”?

  • 1st

    “You make a good point about Canadians being afraid of failure”? More like afraid of winning: At least our Gov. afraid of rub the wrong side of our “partners/neighbors”?

  • TwitterCounter for @markevans
  • Seeking Alpha Certified